Climate change captures an innumerable audience. There is no barrier for entry to say you care about the future in relation to global warming, and it’s an issue that everyone who is anyone can claim a relation to. Unlike other issues like racial inequality or immigrant rights – issues that press against the specific shape of a life–, climate justice can be an issue of contention for any person regardless of their background; you need no particular wound, history, or reckoning. You just need to say: “I like the world I live in. I want to protect it”.
Climate change floats above personal stakes, which sounds like a strength, but it isn’t. Movements that bend the history that we refer to when we talk about “precedent” stem from a few factors that climate change, by nature, cannot have: urgency, the lack of choice, and a specifically ripe political climate in which real action may be done. Niche issues get brought to attention because people in their boats are passionate about it, and for a long period of time at that. Labor movements, suffrage, civil rights, and queer liberation are all examples of movements built by people with no choice but to care. Their urgency was a survival condition that kept the movements coherent. But among all the political and social noise that climate change has moved through, what message is the “movement” actually trying to convey? In the Thunberg years, the general message was to hold governments accountable. “How dare you?” was a message to the Big Man, to repent for the evil he had sown upon the average person. Today, when the issue belongs to everyone, it belongs to no one. The movement looks enormous but ends up hollow at its core, populated by people whose commitment is conditional, passionate in bursts, and retreating when life reasserts its ordinary demands. Opponents have learned this pattern, and companies have circumvented Thunberg’s demands by selling “eco-friendly” shampoo and napkins while clear-cutting the Boreal Forests.
As I have lived it and watched others live it, the average story of a climate empathizer goes like this:
You’re a high school sophomore with a 4.0 GPA and a reasonable certainty about your future, a smugness, in fact. Over lunch, your friends talk about their prospects, and you revel in the fact that you have a pretty much guaranteed future just by your GPA alone, something that they seem to be worrying about. But the person next to you starts talking about their extracurriculars, how they’re worried their supervisor’s letter of recommendation is just from a template and too bland for the Ivy League school they’re applying to.
You had been coasting along until the tide caught you. Going around the table, the next person talks about the non-profit organization they’re thinking of starting, and how “it’s really easy! You just need an adult with a bank account to register on the state’s website”. You know they’re all passionate and driven individuals, but you never thought that my grades alone couldn’t get you by. But what do I even care about?
That afternoon, you go back home and open a new tab. You search for student-led non-profits and organizations you could start a school or even a state chapter for. That seems to be what college admissions consider “well-rounded”. Why climb club leadership when I can just start my own? You find one for climate justice, and the polished website lists a multitude of accomplishments, highlighted by big numbers and percentages. It’s nationally recognized and, according to the banner, impactful. Over the next two years, you start a chapter at my school, organize a rally or two, sit outside a grocery store at a folding table with a sign and a clipboard. It all culminates in sitting at your desk, late October of your senior year, writing the leadership prompt for college admissions. “Which community do you personally identify with, and what have you done to contribute to it?” You find the words: “passionate”, “grassroots”, “environmental justice”, and all of their cousins.
Then, you arrive. You enter the prestigious institution of your– or your parents’ – dreams. Climate change feels like a phase now, like a haircut or an outgrown style. Now bound by the contract to study under an elite private higher-education institution, it’s pretty much an issue of the past. Obviously, you stay aware, and you think back on the high school experiences when a relevant news headline appears, but why would you still care? Climate change isn’t going to go away, and you don’t have a reason to care any more than the next person. Right now, the degree is more important. Not the temperature of the globe.
Later, you start looking for internships and jobs. You discover that the language you learned to mobilize communities has already migrated to a new sector. “Sustainability”, “green commitment”, “zero-emissions”. The words appear in brand guides, billboards, job listings, and you notice them even in the grocery store you used to table at, on mac and cheese packaging and cereal boxes.
You know what greenwashing is, and you are a little shocked by how blatantly some companies will lie to consumers to their face, but you recognize its purpose. The world is becoming globalized, and green energy is the next “big thing”. Your high school experience works to your advantage. The vocabulary you once practiced to show your dedication to being a changemaker and show your commitment to building communities turns out to slide even more easily into interview “one-liners”.
Over time, I’ve noticed a disillusionment with climate change and environmentalism in myself and those around me. The grasp loosens quietly, not as a dramatic exit. I wonder to myself why I care so much about an issue that I, as one individual, will never even comprehend the immensity of. What exactly was I part of?
A lot can be said for the value that a community brings to an individual, but less so when that community only assembles selectively. When they aren’t contained to a niche community facing a specific, urgent issue, climate protests need a certain atmospheric condition to be effective. The political climate needs to be just hot enough, people need to be just angry enough to take action, and leaders need to strike the exact right tone for the momentum to kick off. Protests have continued, and the planet has stayed running on its track, sweating hotter and hotter. A lot of us have settled into the logic that governments and corporations must act, releasing us from the shackles of this inherent responsibility. We view the protests as the base standard of action, and write a permission slip for ourselves to not commit.
In “Against the Machine”, Paul Kingsnorth noticed something about the selective tolerance for protest in our current cultural moment:
“Why, for example, will the new cultural dispensation make excuses for public protest when it is carried out by students protesting about racial injustice or climate change, but condemn it when it comes from truck drivers protesting against vaccine mandates? It’s not because any actual racial justice will be forthcoming, nor because those in power have any intention of reigning in their carbon emissions. It’s because the ‘white working class’ are yesterday’s news: everything we used to be and are now ashamed of. Bigots, racists, Trump-n-Brexit voters, deplorables, gammon. ‘Diversity’, on the other hand, is the future — just as long as it doesn’t upset the economic apple cart or come anywhere near the neighborhood we actually live in.” (Paul Kingsnorth, Against the Machine)
I used to be able to dismiss this kind of argument. When I was younger, I would think that it’s the ethos of the whole thing that matters; the fact that you tried and that you actually care should be enough comfort. But when you’ve gone most of your life under the impression that your individual actions can do something, and then you realize that plastic recycling is a hoax, and just one company’s yearly pollution is the equivalent of hundreds of thousands of people’s lifetime carbon footprint, the outlook is rather bleak. The ground shifts under the moral framework you’d stood on, and Kingsnorth’s diagnosis that contemporary activism is more about identity than outcome, about what you’re against rather than what you’re for, rings uncomfortably close to the truth. That’s why we can’t feel a real sense of passion or genuineness from issues like climate change. That’s why I felt hollow. As it turns out, more explanation does not equate to more hope.
Yet, when I was younger, I was also taught other things. When we are little, our parents teach us to share our toys. Why? Because we develop empathy for other people. This is an inherently good thing. Sharing toys doesn’t solve the crisis of classroom toy shortage; one child releasing a doll into the commons doesn’t change the material conditions of that environment. But the rehearsal of that release builds empathy, a habit of attention.
We need to do the same when it comes to environmentalism. The climate movement skipped this crucial step. It has always asked for people to perform belief by showing up, signing petitions, tagging the cause, when in reality, sustainable movements form much more quietly. Teach kids green habits, not because it will make a real impact, but because they grow up to be more socially and environmentally conscious. They pay attention to what they consume, to where things come from, and where they go. This doesn’t guarantee that they will be activists, nor should we necessarily expect that of them.
If they do end up joining those kinds of organizations and doing things just for the sake of how they look, then at least it comes from a place of genuine curiosity. That curiosity will carry through university and even after. When confronted with moral dilemmas, they will be more aware of their individual choices. That is the kind of awareness that truly fuels changes. Ultimately, an environmentalist doesn’t need to be an activist. If a person is an empath, and they care about their personal and physical surroundings, that makes them an environmental citizen. It is time we rethink the approach to climate protest. In this quiet, more durable way, we may see more environmental citizens than we thought.
Coco Wang-Xinyue Zhang is a student at Duke Kunshan University studying Environmental Policy. Originally from Las Vegas, her passion for the environment started with water conservation and designing ocean-safe plastic straws for a middle school competition. Using her experiences in teaching and community organizations, her studies focus on comparisons of education and urban infrastructure in the U.S. and China. Coco is Chief Sustainability Officer and President of Sustainable DKU, Duke Kunshan University’s leading student environmental engagement organization.