Acid to Alive: The Story of Cheat Lake

On any warm summer day, Cheat Lake looks like many of America’s most treasured recreational spaces. All summer long, you will see dozens of boats and kayaks dotting the water and anglers lining up to fish the shoreline. The warm sun greets all those who come to hike and run the trails in the parks around the lake or swim along the lake’s beaches, unless you come anytime after September. Though the fall colors at Cheat Lake are beautiful and are worth seeing despite the chilly weather. Only an hour and a half from Pittsburgh, and even less than that from Maryland, it is used for recreation by people from all over the tri-state area. The Cheat has been used for swimming, boating, fishing, and kayaking for nearly the entire time it’s been around. Despite the Cheat being widely used for outdoor enjoyment, it wasn’t created for recreational purposes. This man-made lake, tucked along the forested hills of northern West Virginia, was created when they dammed the Cheat River to produce electricity.

Early History of Cheat Lake

Cheat Lake, originally called Lake Lynn, was created in 1926 when the West Penn Power Company built the Lake Lynn Dam across the Cheat River for a hydroelectric power project. The hydroelectric facility remains in operation today. Many property owners had to give up land for the project and the small mining communities of Cheat Haven and Rockley were flooded. When you look at the early history of the lake, the construction of the Lake Lynn Dam might seem like it was the most significant change to the Cheat’s landscapes and communities. However, it would ultimately be the coal industry that left the most damaging environmental legacy on the Cheat.

Acid Mine Drainage and Coal’s Legacy

Like most places in West Virginia, coal mining was widespread throughout the Cheat River area in the late nineteenth century and throughout the twentieth century. Coal mining boosted the region’s economy and provided many jobs until the 1960s, when it began to decline. As the coal seams were exhausted, many mining companies in the Cheat Lake area abandoned and closed their mines. The mines left behind had many underground passages and openings that allowed groundwater and rainwater to move through the exposed rock. Water that passed through these abandoned mines came into contact with pyrite, a common mineral found in coal deposits. When this iron-rich mineral interacts with water and oxygen, it causes chemical reactions that produce sulfuric acid and iron oxides. The most harmful part is that the acidic water can dissolve metals like iron, manganese, and aluminum in nearby rocks and carry them out of the abandoned mines into surrounding streams. This process, known as acid mine drainage (AMD), has devastated streams, rivers, and lakes all over Appalachia.

The problems AMD caused the Cheat were impossible to ignore. The contaminated water from the underground abandoned mines flowed into tributaries of the lake first. By the 1970s, the iron and other minerals carried by the polluted water had made its way into the Cheat and the water and rocks were coated in a very distinct orange color. The lake became so acidic that a lot of the aquatic life began to die off and people started experiencing other things as well. Paddlers and anglers that had enjoyed the calm waters of the Cheat for decades began reporting something unusual. Reports of burning eyes and frequent nosebleeds started popping up from people who visited the lake and made contact with the polluted water.

The Cheat’s Breaking Point

During an unusually wet and unpredictable spring in 1994, areas around the Cheat began experiencing flooding. This historic flooding was so powerful that it caused contaminated mine water to bust out the side of a hillside. The AMD concentrated water entered Muddy Creek, one of the Cheat’s tributaries, and the outcome was devastating. According to the Friends of Cheat, a local grassroots organization that was founded to respond to this environmental disaster, tens of thousands of gallons of polluted water entered into the tributary. Miles of the Cheat River and Cheat Lake turned orange and the water smelled of rotten eggs. Orange iron sludge was visible on all the rocks lining the shore. That summer in 1994 looked a lot different than the one originally described.

One would think that we should pursue legal action against the operating mine that diverted water into the abandoned mine, right? Unfortunately, this wasn’t an option. In 1977, Congress passed the Surface Mining Control and Reclamation Act which was meant to require coal companies to reclaim mine land. Before this federal legislation there was nothing really stopping the companies from just leaving behind mines. They couldn’t be responsible for what happened after they abandoned it. Unfortunately, for the Cheat Lake area most of the mines that were abandoned and causing problems were left behind by coal companies before the SMCRA was passed in 1977. The burden fell upon community members and state agencies like the West Virginia Department of Environmental Protection.

The Community Rallies and Fights Back

Following the 1994 AMD blowout at Muddy Creek, concerned citizens formed a grassroots non-profit organization called Friends of the Cheat. This group of locals had simple goals to get the lake back that they loved and enjoyed for decades. They were founded to restore the Cheat Lake and Cheat River and then to eventually preserve it once it was able to get back on its feet. From the beginning this organization began acting as a connector to get cooperation among state and federal government agencies, Cheat Lake communities, and other environmental groups in West Virginia. They worked with each other to identify the abandoned mines that were the sources for all the contaminated water entering the Cheat. They worked on one stream and mine at a time and developed a system that worked well. They worked with the WVDEP to create a treatment system for the contaminated water to reduce the metals and acidity before it reached the Cheat. Since 1995, Friends of the Cheat have built 20 different acid mine drainage treatment systems on abandoned mine lands.

The Cheat’s Recovery

Friends of the Cheat worked for decades to produce the results that make the Cheat Lake the excellent place that it is today. Looking back at what they have done in such a short time seems kind of impossible. However, the water quality has been gradually improving in the Cheat Watershed area ever since 1995. Concentrations of iron and aluminum have decreased because the treatment systems built by Friends of the Cheat have prevented most of the AMD concentrated water from reaching the main lake and river.

The best indicators of this recovery are in the changes to the fish populations. Thousands of fish died because of the 1994 environmental disaster and ecosystems in the Cheat area were devastated by the highly acidic water. However, today fish have returned to areas of the Cheat they haven’t been seen in since before 1994. One study found that the aquatic life in the area was able to make a fast recovery with no fish being recorded by the mouth of the Muddy Creek tributary. Four years later after the Friends of the Cheat began treatments on the area there were more than 143 fish found at the mouth of 9 different species.

It’s because of the work of Friends of Cheat that people have been able to enjoy whitewater rafting on the Cheat again for the first time in decades. Anglers are beginning to fish the waters again and they often line the shore anytime of year. The recovery efforts by the state and local organizations have been great. They have helped restore the Cheat a lot faster than most would have believed possible.


Rachel Carson Campus National Environment Leadership Fellow – Andrew O’Neal

Andrew is a junior at studying Political Science and Sustainability Studies. He has been involved with advocacy work since high school when he served as West Virginia’s first youth governor. Andrew serves as chair of the Sustainability Committee in WVU’s Student Government Association where his work focuses on bringing solar energy projects on campus and creating opportunities for students to get outdoors and involved in environmental advocacy.