The cold October air blows across my face as I sit forty feet aloft the open water. I’m sixteen, and in the midst of the ever changing chaos of teenage life, the water seems to be the only place that feels like home.
The waves below are rough, and the higher you climb, the more you feel them. Every swell rocks the mast beneath us, swaying us above the river. They send me to the top because I am young, and perhaps a little too willing. To some it is terrifying, but I love the thrill. I need the adrenaline.
I am not up there just for the view. There are sails to manually furl, lines to untangle, and rigging to wrestle into place. Yet somewhere in the turbulence of the waves, I find an unexpected kind of calm. The air is frigid, my hands ache from gripping rope, and still the herons glide quietly over the river below us, seemingly untouched by any of it. For a moment, the rest of the world feels very far away.
That fall I worked as a historian at Historic St. Mary’s City, a museum tucked along the southern tip of Maryland’s western shore, where the state’s first English settlement once stood. I had practically been raised there, wandering its paths, growing up alongside its stories, but I never imagined I would one day be a sailor aboard its hallmark tall ship, the Maryland Dove, coasting through the waters of the St. Mary’s River, a tributary of the Chesapeake Bay.
It was, in every sense, my dream job. My days were filled with people who traveled from around the county, just to step aboard the ship I had begun to think of as a second home. I sewed by hand, hauled lines, climbed rigging, sailed the river, and spent quiet moments reading about people who had crossed these same waters centuries before me. History stopped feeling like something confined to books or museum displays. Out there, with the river beneath my feet and canvas swaying overhead, it felt alive.
But despite all its beauty, there were moments when I envied the people who had sailed these waters centuries before me.
The St. Mary’s River is one of the Chesapeake’s luckier tributaries. Compared with much of the watershed, its waters remain relatively healthy, making it an imperfect place to tell a story of a Bay in decline. From forty feet above the water, it is especially easy to convince myself that little has changed. The shoreline still folds into the quiet coves. Herons still stalk the shallows, and ospreys still circle overhead. The same wind that once filled the sails of wooden ships now catches ours.
But the St. Mary’s is only one small piece of a much larger watershed. Beyond these quiet shores, the Chesapeake is struggling. The water miles out is murky. Dark. Quiet.
I love the Chesapeake. It’s my home. I know its marshes and muddy shorelines, the smell of brackish water in the muggy summertime wind, the blue crabs and barnacles tucked beneath the dock. I know the particular comfort of returning to the water and recognizing it.
But sometimes, loving a place means noticing the ways it is falling apart.
The Chesapeake has become something of an old family house, deeply loved, incessantly familiar, and slowly deteriorating around the people who call it home. The walls of its shoreline are crumbling. The marshes disappear room by room. Beneath the surface, the once vast oyster reefs have collapsed, underwater grasses have vanished from places they once covered, and its inhabitants have grown fewer and fewer. Still, there are traces of what this house once was.
When European explorers entered the Chesapeake in the early seventeenth century, they wrote of a world almost unimaginable from where I sail from today. Fish were so abundant that they lay “so thick with their heads above the water” that, lacking nets, the men tried to catch them with a frying pan. The oyster reefs rose through the shallows, so abundant that they collectively could filter the entire volume of Bay water in just 7 days. Beneath them stretched underwater meadows of grasses, nurseries for the creatures that made their homes here.
And long before the Europeans mapped these waters, long before Maryland had a name, people lived along the rivers that fed this estuary. For thousands of years, Indigenous communities traveled these waters, fished them, gathered food from their shores, and built lives around the rhythms of the Bay. I think about them sometimes when I am aloft.
From forty feet above the river, my hands wrapped around the rigging, centuries begin to feel small. People before me watched herons lift from these same marshes. They followed these rivers home; they knew the pull of tides and the changing of the seasons. They loved people here. They lost people. They depended upon this water just as generations after them would. And now, so do I.
Perhaps that is why watching the Chesapeake struggle feels so personal. A home does not stop being home once the roof begins to leak, or the foundation starts to crack. You begin to learn where the floorboards creak. You place a bucket beneath the leak. You are accustomed to the cracks in the walls until eventually you almost stop seeing them. But familiarity is not the same thing as stability.
From the rigging of the Maryland Dove, I can look across the Chesapeake and love her completely, for what she is, what she was, and for everything she has given the people who have lived along her shores. But loving a home should not mean accepting its collapse.
The Chesapeake is an old house, battered by generations of use, with rooms we have neglected and inhabitants we have lost. But it is not an empty house. And it is not yet condemned. There is still life in the walls. There is still something here worth restoring.
Ava Ciabattoni – Penn State University
Ava Ciabattoni is a senior at Penn State University majoring in Pharmacology & Toxicology with a minor in Wildlife & Fisheries Science. Growing up in southern Maryland with the Chesapeake Bay as her backyard, she developed an early interest in coastal ecosystems and the connections between environmental and human health. Her research interests center on ecotoxicology, food systems, and understanding how agricultural and industrial contaminants affect ecosystem health and function.